Episode 005 · Part 1 · Recorded October 22, 2026

Your Third Brain Should Make You Stronger, Not Just Faster

Part 1 of 2 with Jack Myers. AI can give you every option. Choosing still belongs to a human, and so does owning the result.

With Jack Myers, Author, Your Third Brain · The Tao of Leadership

Your Third Brain, Part 2: The Return on AI Is Each Other →

One idea

Jack Myers' third brain is not the AI. It's our own intelligence working co-intelligently with machines, and its job is to make the first two stronger. AI brings volume, recall and speed, and it can lay out every option. What stays human is the judgment: a vault of notes has none of its own, and neither does the AI that reads it. What changed is how easy it has become to hand the decision over, so the rule is simple: never let a decision be made that some human is not accountable for.

Show notes

Overview

Every community manager now works alongside a machine that reads faster, remembers more and drafts better first passes than any person on the team. That is useful, and it is also unsettling, because the skills many of us built our careers on are the ones the machine does best. The real question for the work is not whether to use AI. It is what stays ours when we do: the judgment, the choices, and the responsibility for what happens next.

Chris Heuer sits down with Jack Myers, the author of Your Third Brain and The Tao of Leadership, for the first of two conversations. Jack lays out the idea behind the book, a third brain that is co-intelligent with machines, and makes the case that its purpose is to make us stronger. Chris tests that idea against a vault of notes, his own memory, and the way companies are actually rolling AI out. Part 1 ends where the whole idea turns: on who is accountable when the machine gives the answer.

Three brains

Jack opens the episode with his definition. The first brain is the biological one we are born with, the one we use to learn and to teach. The second is our cultural and social brain, the one that connects us to the rest of the world, much of which now lives in social media. The third brain is co-intelligent with machines. For the first time, there is something more intelligent than we are in many areas, though that does not mean it is more capable in every way.

Jack prefers to call it techno intelligence, or accelerated intelligence, rather than artificial intelligence. Look up intelligence in the dictionary, he points out, and the word human isn’t there. The point of the third brain is to expand and amplify the intelligence we already have. Its job is to strengthen the first brain and the second, and help both grow.

He is careful about one line. Machines can imitate feelings well enough to make us think they have them. They don’t feel. Keeping our own agency over what we feel, and how we use those feelings to connect with each other, is part of the work.

A vault doesn’t have judgment

Many people building with AI today talk about a second brain: the files, notes, research and writing they keep in one place, a vault an AI can read. Chris asks Jack where that fits. Jack’s answer reframes it. A vault is the first brain’s work, collected and stored. It becomes part of a third brain only when you open it up and work with it, asking the AI for options and opportunities.

What the vault doesn’t have is judgment. The discernment you bring to the choices, and the decision you make at the end, are still yours. Jack’s concern is that we cede that right to the machine, rather than constantly challenging it to help us make better choices.

The cost to memory and identity

Chris brings the worry closer to home. He feels his own memory slipping, partly from age and partly from processing far more information than he can sit with and digest. Learning research points to the friction of challenge as part of how we learn and retain, and he wonders whether we are moving too fast for our brains to keep up. Jack asks a different question: does the brain need to keep up? He expects AI to help with memory loss, through glasses, hearing devices and, eventually, direct connections to the brain, and he expects the technology to arrive before society is ready for it.

Then Chris says the harder part out loud. Near photographic memory and a fast mind had been his identity since he was a kid. When Claude writes exactly what he is trying to say, he feels the machine is better than him. Jack’s answer is personal too. He has never been able to memorize, which is why he became a writer and not an actor, and his hardest talk ever was a TED Women talk where every word had to land on one of more than a hundred slide advances.

Chris finds his footing there. He can’t memorize a speech either. He shows up, stays present, and connects with the room, and that is when he is at his best. AI does three things very well: volume of data, recall of that data, and speed. People bring empathy, judgment, creativity and discernment, and confidence in those grows with experience. Working with AI as a thought partner is still new, so that confidence is still being built.

An AI strategy, and no human strategy

Jack widens the frame. AI changes the culture of an organization or a community, not only its workflow, and it can break down the silos that keep people apart. Yet the public conversation stays on data centers and politics. Every company and educational institution now has an AI strategy, and few have a human strategy for the people who are empowered by AI and the people who lose their jobs to it.

Chris has watched this happen for decades: enterprise technology projects overfund the technology and underfund the training and growth of the people who use it. Jack points to what has happened to human resources and diversity work, cut back while the AI budgets grow. Chris tells his story of the employee ordered to open a valve and release chemicals into a river, someone with a mortgage and kids headed to college who feels he has no real choice. Jack turns the metaphor around. Open the other valve, he says: the one that lets ethics, integrity, judgment, purpose and belonging flow. AI can help with that too. Faced with a request that seems wrong, you can ask it for realistic options for how to respond, and then make the choice yourself.

Someone has to own the decision

Jack tells the story at the center of the episode. One of his clients, a C-suite leader, asked his team who was responsible for a decision that had gone wrong. One team member answered that the AI told them to do it. Jack’s advice to that organization is the rule of this whole conversation:

“never let a decision be made that some human is not accountable for.” (Jack Myers, 31:10)

Chris worries about the slippery slope. A society built for following orders, now handed a tool with superior recall and speed, will be tempted to go along without pausing. He also has a story that points the other way. While building a demo of Net Trust Score, a site that shows no score until thirty people have responded, he asked Claude to make the demo look fuller. Claude read the request as asking for fake data, and reminded him that a site about trust can’t show fake data. The right system, set up the right way, can lead toward better moral decisions. It depends on the system and the biases in it, and on whether the organization has any system of accountability at all. Chris left Deloitte to build one, and learned that no one wanted to be held accountable.

Measuring the human contribution

Jack closes Part 1 with two pieces of his recent work. The first, on The Myers Report, his Substack, looks at how Wall Street’s demand for efficiency is reshaping media companies carrying heavy debt, at the expense of the content and relationships that built them. The second is his proposal for AI creator trust standards. He calls people who work with AI creators, not users, and argues that the human contribution, from the first prompt to the final output, should be measured and shown, not hidden behind the last thing the AI produced.

When we pay attention to our human contribution, and to the choices we make at every step, Jack says, we start to build a better society, culture and community.

What’s next

In Part 2, Chris and Jack take the conversation from the boardroom to the rest of us: what AI is costing people, and what the return on it should be. Before then, try one thing this week. The next time an AI hands you an answer, write down the decision you are making with it and put your own name next to it.

Chapters

Time Chapter
00:00 Cold open: Jack’s three brains
01:19 Welcome, Jack Myers
03:49 The pause
05:15 Are we replacing thinking?
07:03 The premise of Your Third Brain
08:27 Techno intelligence, not artificial intelligence
10:58 Is a vault a second brain?
13:37 Cognitive decline and too much to read
17:12 Our sponsor: Higher Logic
17:59 Memory, identity and “it’s better than me”
21:34 What AI does well, and what we do well
23:26 An AI strategy, but no human strategy
27:05 Opening the other valve
30:16 “The AI told us to do it”
31:21 Following orders, and an AI that refused fake data
33:24 Wall Street, efficiency and AI creator trust
36:30 Coming up in Part 2

Key takeaways

  • The third brain is there to make you stronger. Jack’s first brain is biological, his second is cultural and social, and the third is co-intelligent with machines. Its job is to strengthen the other two.
  • Call it accelerated intelligence. Intelligence was never defined as only human. The value is in how machine intelligence amplifies our own.
  • A vault has no judgment. Your notes and files are the first brain’s work, stored. They become a third brain when you work with them, and the choices are still yours.
  • Machines imitate feelings; they don’t feel. Keeping agency over our own feelings is part of how we connect with each other.
  • Speed, recall and volume are the machine’s. Empathy, judgment, creativity and discernment are ours, and confidence in them grows with experience.
  • Identity is part of the cost. When the skill you were known for becomes the thing AI does best, the loss is personal, not only professional.
  • Every company has an AI strategy. Few have a human strategy for the people AI empowers and the people it displaces.
  • Open the other valve. Use AI to find realistic options when you’re asked to do something wrong, then make the choice yourself.
  • A human owns every decision. “The AI told us to do it” is not an answer. Someone has to be accountable.
  • Measure the human contribution. Jack’s AI creator trust proposal treats people who work with AI as creators and shows what they contributed, not only what the AI produced.

CommunityAssistant.ai Links

Co-host & sponsor

In this episode

About the show

CommunityAssistant.ai is the podcast and open resource library exploring the human work of community management: what AI can take off your plate, what only you can do, and how to grow into the role that’s coming. Hosted by Chris Heuer and Marius Ciortea. Season sponsor: Higher Logic.

Our sponsor. CommunityAssistant.ai is made possible by Higher Logic, supporting the practitioners who build the communities that matter.

Our independence. Sponsors make this show possible. They don’t make this show. Marius works at Higher Logic; he appears here as a practitioner speaking for himself, not for his employer.

Clips

The third brain's job

Jack Myers on what the third brain is for: making the first brain and the second brain stronger.

View and share video clips as:Vertical Video

Memory loss, corrected

Is there a human decline as machine cognition grows? Jack thinks machines can help correct memory loss, and that it's happening now.

It's better than me

Chris on losing the near-photographic memory he's always had, and Jack on why the next five years could give it back with more depth.

View and share video clips as:Vertical Video

An AI strategy, but no human strategy

Every company has an AI strategy. Jack asks how many have a human strategy.

Three things AI does well

Chris on what AI does better than we do, volume, recall and speed, and what we do that it can't: empathy, judgment, creativity and discernment.

The power of the pause

Jack on the pause as one of the most important human capabilities, comparable in power to what the machines can do.

Made with Claude, not by it · CC BY-NC 4.0